Justice Brennan: A Liberal Icon Gets Another Look : NPR

Image via WikipediaJustice Brennan: A Liberal Icon Gets Another Look : NPR

While the U.S. Supreme Court today is dominated by conservatives, it still abides by many of the landmark decisions written by the court's liberal icon, Justice William J. Brennan Jr., who retired in 1990 after 34 years of service.

This fall, a long-awaited biography, Justice Brennan: Liberal Champion, is on the nation's bookshelves — an account of Brennan's life, times and influence on the nation's highest court.

For those not familiar with Brennan's incredible record, let us recapitulate. As the conservative National Review put it in writing about the liberal justice: "An examination of Brennan's opinions, and his influence upon the opinions of his colleagues, suggests that there is no individual in this country, on or off the Court, who has had a more profound and sustained impact on public policy in the United States."

Justice Brennan: Liberal Champion

By Seth Stern and Stephen Wermiel

Hardcover, 688 pages

Houghton Mifflin Harcourt

List price: $35

Brennan's legacy is spelled out in more than 1,300 legal opinions — from Baker v. Carr, his opinion for the court establishing the "one person, one vote" principle in legislative apportionment, to his passionate dissents on the death penalty.

For reasons that even the book's authors cannot fathom, Brennan agreed in the mid-1980s to cooperate on a biography with Stephen Wermiel, then of The Wall Street Journal and now a law professor at American University. The justice asked for nothing in return, not even editorial control. Wermiel spent four concentrated years with Brennan while the justice was still on the bench. The biographer had unfettered access to Brennan's papers, and unparalleled access to the justice. Not only was Wermiel permitted to be something of a fly on the wall in the Brennan chambers, but the justice also sat for more than 60 hours of tape-recorded interviews.

More...

Related articles

• Author stresses Justice Brennan's continued relevance (cnn.com)
• Justice Brennan: Liberal Champion misses the secret of his vision. (slate.com)
• Sidebar: Brennan's Biographer Took His Time (nytimes.com)
• Getting to Five (nytimes.com)

Justice Brennan: Liberal Champion - CSMonitor.com

Justice Brennan: Liberal Champion - CSMonitor.com

William Brennan was probably the most liberal US Supreme Court justice in the post-World War II era. Embracing a progressive, expansive view of “equal protection” under the law, Brennan rejected discrimination against blacks, women, gays, and the poor. In the realm of criminal justice, Brennan’s controversial decisions enlarged the legal protections granted to suspects, providing them a bolstered right to silence, the right to court-appointed public defenders, and more.

Even more controversially, Brennan carved out a constitutionally protected “right to privacy” that would pave the way for 1973’s “Roe v. Wade” decision.

While Brennan’s brand of liberal judicial activism thrived in the 1960s (during the tenure of his friend, Chief Justice Earl Warren), the last two decades of his long term (1956-90) saw a conservative backlash, as right-wing politicians (like Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan) joined forces with “strict constructionist” judges (like William Rehnquist and Antonin Scalia) to roll back many of Brennan’s progressive rulings.

Authors Seth Stern and Stephen Wermiel are both legal scholars and journalists who have a deep understanding of how the Supreme Court works. Wermiel actually interviewed Brennan dozens of times before the “liberal champion” died in 1997; Wermiel was also given access to Brennan’s files and notes, allowing the authors a true “behind the scenes” look at some of the most important Supreme Court decisions of the last half century. As a work of legal analysis, Justice Brennan provides unique insights into Brennan’s own legal thinking and how he lobbied other justices to support his views.

The authors also describe Brennan’s middle-class, Irish-American childhood as the son of a Jersey City politician. Indeed, Brennan gained many of his legendary political skills from watching his dad: young Brennan “observed ... the way Bill [Senior] remembered names and faces and could fit in so comfortably at a firehouse or corner tavern,” the authors write. But beyond Brennan’s undeniable affability, we never see into the deeper recesses of Brennan’s character.

The authors describe Brennan’s successful early career as a New Jersey lawyer. He displayed his proclivities for helping the poor when he volunteered at Harvard Law School’s Legal Aid Bureau, where the future judge (and then law student) represented poor clients. After becoming a New Jersey state judge, Brennan was chosen by President Dwight Eisenhower to fill an opening on the Supreme Court. Ike, the authors explain, expected the selection to help him win Roman Catholic votes in 1956. (And it did.) Once on the bench, however, Brennan, and fellow Eisenhower-appointee Warren, would greatly disappoint the Republican president.

Brennan was courted by two legal giants, Felix Frankfurter and Earl Warren. Frankfurter’s stunning intelligence was matched only by his social insensitivity. His method of persuasion involved pompously lecturing his listeners until they accepted his opinion. Brennan understandably distanced himself. With Warren, the affable former governor of California, Brennan forged a partnership throughout the 1960s that would alter American legal history.

In a series of decisions skillfully described by the authors, Brennan would promote civil rights, extend fuller protections to the press, revolutionize the criminal process by expanding protections for suspects, curb the death penalty, and create a new role for the Supreme Court as a protector of individual liberty.

More...

Related articles by Zemanta

• You: Sidebar: Brennan's Biographer Took His Time (nytimes.com)
• Justice Brennan (politicalwire.com)
• You: Clerks Highlight Supreme Court's Polarization (nytimes.com)